HTMA vs Blood Tests vs Hormone Tests: What Each Can (and Can’t) Tell You in Menopause

By the time many women reach late perimenopause or postmenopause, they’ve usually had multiple blood tests, perhaps hormone testing, and often a growing sense that none of it quite explains how they feel. Understanding what each type of test is designed to show can help explain why that happens.

How do HTMA, blood tests, and hormone tests differ in menopause?

Blood tests show what is regulated in circulation at a single point in time, hormone tests reflect hormone levels or patterns over short periods, and HTMA highlights longer-term mineral balance and stress adaptation at a tissue level. Each test answers a different question, and none is designed to tell the whole story on its own.

If you’re new to mineral testing, you may find it helpful to read What Is Hair Tissue Mineral Analysis (HTMA) and What Does It Actually Show? First. You can read that HERE.

What blood tests are good at

Don’t get me wrong, blood tests are essential. They are designed to identify:

  • deficiencies that require medical treatment

  • disease markers

  • organ function issues

  • safety and risk factors

In menopause, blood tests are often used to assess things like iron status, thyroid markers, glucose control, and general health. But when these results come back within range (and you still don’t feel right), it usually means the body is still maintaining tight control in the bloodstream.

What blood tests don’t always show is how hard the body is working to keep things looking normal.

What hormone tests can tell you

Hormone tests can be helpful for understanding:

  • whether you are in perimenopause or postmenopause

  • patterns of hormone fluctuation

  • how symptoms may relate to hormonal signalling

  • If hormone production is extremely low

However, hormones don’t act in isolation. Their effects depend heavily on nutritional status, stress physiology, and metabolic picture. This is why hormone results alone don’t always explain fatigue, anxiety, or poor stress tolerance.

Hormone tests describe signals. They don’t always explain capacity.

What HTMA adds to the picture

HTMA looks at mineral patterns over time rather than snapshots. Minerals are involved in:

  • energy production

  • nervous system regulation

  • blood sugar control

  • stress response and recovery

In menopause, HTMA can help highlight patterns that suggest long-term depletion, compensation, or imbalance, particularly when symptoms persist despite reassuring blood or hormone results.

It doesn’t replace other tests. It adds context.

Why one test is rarely enough

Each type of test answers a different question:

  • Blood tests ask, “Is anything dangerously out of range?”

  • Hormone tests ask, “What is happening with hormonal signalling?”

  • HTMA asks, “How well is the body coping and adapting over time?”

When symptoms are mild or short-lived, one test may be enough. When symptoms are persistent, layered, or confusing, a broader view is often more helpful.

Why menopause exposes gaps in testing

Menopause tends to reduce the body’s tolerance for inefficiency. Adaptations that once worked quietly in the background become harder to sustain.

This is why many women notice that:

  • results haven’t changed, but they have

  • what used to work no longer does

  • pushing harder leads to worse recovery

Understanding the strengths and limits of different tests can remove a lot of self-blame and confusion.

A balanced approach

A thoughtful approach to menopause support doesn’t dismiss conventional testing, and it doesn’t rely on a single tool to explain everything. It recognises that physiology is layered and that different tests offer different lenses.

For many women, clarity comes not from “finding the right test”, but from understanding how the pieces fit together.

Where to go next

If you want a clearer explanation of how mineral testing fits alongside blood and hormone tests when menopause symptoms persist, I walk through this in a short 15-minute video designed to help you decide what makes sense for your situation.

Watch the video.

Get Your Free

Scorecard

Find out what your personal energy + mood score is today!

Work With Me

Struggling with symptoms like low energy, stubborn weight, low mood, low motivation, brain fog... and so on? Find out how I can help you, and why I'm different to most menopause practitioners...

Join The Community

Reclaim Your Best Self With A Community That Cares

Going through menopause can be a challenging period for women of all ages. Hot flashes, mood swings, and fatigue can make it difficult for women to keep up with their daily routines and take care of themselves. That is why it is essential to have a supportive community of women who are going through similar experiences and can provide comfort and understanding.

Get In Touch

Join Our Community!

Take Control Of Your Menopause and Weight Loss - For Women Over 40

Meet thousands of other women over 40 who are on the same journey inside our Facebook group.


Copyright 2023 | Vanessa Obagi, The Menopause Specialist | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions